New York Sandwich Shop

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.5

( 8 reviews )

Delis, Sandwiches

Closed 10:30 AM - 04:00 PM See Hours

593 Joseph E Lowery Blvd SW, Atlanta, GA 30310, United States

+1 4047-556-658

New York Sandwich Shop is a popular eatery located in the bustling city of New York. Known for its delicious sandwiches made with fresh ingredients, the sandwich shop has gained a loyal following of locals and tourists alike. The menu boasts a range of options, including classic deli meats like pastrami and corned beef, as well as Polish sausage and steak and cheese. Additionally, customers can enjoy sides like potato salad and take advantage of the shop's takeout offerings. With a focus on quality ingredients and excellent customer service, New York Sandwich Shop has become a go-to spot for those in search of a satisfying meal in the heart of the city.

Amenities and More

Takeaway
Accepts reservations
Plenty of parking
Quick bite
Historic

Reviews

4.5/5

8 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Brooke langley

March 22, 2024

Two very nice ladies waited on me. Ordered a Reuben and a Polish sausage and a bottle of water. The Reuben wasn't fancy but it wasn't 7-8 bucks either. It was good though. It started getting busy as I was leaving but I'd return to try some more items.

Wendy zhong

March 22, 2024

First time visiting today. I live in the area and have driven past this location many times. This is one of those IYKYK spots. There was a short line inside(good sign). I asked the person in front of me her opinion of food, and she highly approved. The prices are surprisingly low. I got a corned beef sandwich it was decent. Didn't quite hit Lou's Deli deliciousness back in Detroit. I'll try a different sandwich on the next visit.

Nathaniel blair

March 22, 2024

I used to be a very sandwich loving person. Since I discovered this place, I have become even more fond of eating sandwiches. Sometimes I buy many and take them home for a whole day.

Rachel oligney

March 22, 2024

Two ladies who work their butts off to make really delicious cheap sandwiches. My partner and I get the corned beef and pastrami subs here at least once a week! And the potato salad is some of the best I've ever had. Just make sure to bring cash!

Ronald bryant

March 22, 2024

Remembered this place from the early 2000's, so I had to take the drive and it was sooo well worth it. First and foremost the price of the sandwiches here is unbelievable, you can get get 3 sandwiches for $20 bucks, then there is the way they fix the sandwiches, then of course then there's the taste. The Polish sausage is a good choice, the taste of the sausage and the mustard, great combination. Also ordered the Broadway sandwich, which consist of Bologna, salami, and ham and cheese, also another good tasting sandwich. This place is MOST DEFINITELY a gem. Whenever I am wanting a sandwich this will be my spot and well worth the drive

Ryan wright

March 22, 2024

Sandwiches are the bomb. Reminds me of New York style deli ..like really really good! Don’t throw stones at me for this but I do believe that a Korean family (2 female siblings) run this place. Does it matter, maybe not but it’s in the middle of a rough black neighborhood just for geography info. Sparked up some good quick convos with folks when it’s busy though..which is often especially during lunch. The sandwiches are extremely delicious though and always consistent. The women that run it are very sweet and I feel good pulling up here and spending my money. A must visit if you want to see some real ATL.

Shannon martin

March 22, 2024

Fantastic, 5-star neighborhood institution. Ladies that run it are so sweet. Can’t-beat prices (cash only). You might wait a short bit. Try the hot steak and cheese!

Jeff devlieger

March 22, 2024

Just based off the smell of the store and the meat sitting in tubs, was enough for me to walk back out. Not to mention that they only give you American cheese and not provolone for a sub and only accept cash as a form of payment!!!! I’ll make my own!!!